Question: How Do You Respond To A Peer Reviewer Comment?

How do you comment on a peer review?

We’ve rounded up 4 pieces of advice from scholars around the web to help you produce more helpful peer review comments.Avoid decision fatigue.

How many decisions have you made on an average day by 11AM.

List the positives and then the negatives.

Give concrete examples and advice.

Don’t be afraid to seek support..

How do you do peer review?

DoJustify your recommendation with concrete evidence and specific examples.Be specific so the authors know what they need to do to improve.Be thorough. This might be the only time you read the manuscript.Be professional and respectful. … Remember to say what you liked about the manuscript!

How do you write a reviewer comment?

– Begin your review with a concise summary of the essential points of the paper both for the editor’s use and to ensure that you have understood the work. – Next, evaluate the quality of the work. Give evaluations and comments on each of the publication criteria by following the sections of the reviewer report form.

How do you respond to a reviewer comment Journal example?

I am/We are grateful to the reviewers for their insightful comments on my paper. I/We have been able to incorporate changes to reflect most of the suggestions provided by the reviewers. I/We have highlighted the changes within the manuscript.

What should I say in a good review?

Examples of Good ReviewsDetailed, Specific, and Honest. A useful review includes enough detail to give others a feel for what happened. … Calls-Out Stellar Customer Service. 70% of U.S. consumers say they’ve spent more money to do business with a company that delivers excellent service. … Provides Constructive Criticism. … Features Images.

How do you respond to a 5 star review?

“We are so grateful for your 5-star review. Thanks for sharing your rating with us and the community.” “Thank you for the 5 star rating.” “Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us a 5 star rating – it’s much appreciated!”

How do you respond to a journal acceptance?

If your paper has been accepted with no requested changes then there is no need to reply to the editor. If you want, there’s no reason why you can’t can’t send a short email thanking them for accepting your paper or asking what comes next (if this is your first submission to that journal).

What should I write in a good review?

​8 tips for writing great customer reviewsProvide useful, constructive feedback.Talk about a range of elements, including customer service.Be detailed, specific, and honest.Leave out links and personal information.Keep it civil and friendly.Feel free to update your review if needed.Check you’ve got the right domain name or company.Proofread your review.

How do you respond positively?

Here’s how you should respond to positive reviews:Respond quickly. Even if a customer gives you a positive review, you shouldn’t sit back and relax. … Acknowledge them by name. … Show some gratitude. … Provide additional value. … Encourage them to advocate. … Include a friendly sign-off. … Positive Review Response Examples.

How do you respond to a reviewer?

How to reply to reviewersHave a clear structure. … Start with a kind intro thanking editor and reviewers. … Be precise and respond to every single comment. … Challenge the reviewers, if need be. … Show some ‘blood’ … Exploit differences between reviewers to your benefit. … Incorporate most, if not all of the additional literature the reviewers suggest.More items…•

How do you respond to referee comments?

It will be reasonable to begin the letter with a sentence like” Thank you for giving me a chance of revising my manuscript.” Your responses should be scientific, and systematic. You may get help from other authors or before sending your reply you may ask other authors to read, and review your manuscript.

How do you respond to reviewer comments the calm way?

How to respond to reviewer comments – the CALM wayC: Comprehend (keep your cool!) When the decision letter arrives, read over the comments…Take time to understand the reviewers’ feedback and consider what they are asking you to do. … A: Answer (amend or advocate!) … L: List (make a list… … M: Mindful (make it easy for the editor – they will appreciate it!)